Should
American Jews weigh in when it comes to the Israeli elections?
No.
Citizens of Israel, who defend Israel, who face the risks and pay the price for living in Israel decide who leads the country. That’s the blessing of a democratic State of Israel.
Can
American Jews weigh in regarding moral issues and Jewish
values? Absolutely.
This has
become especially relevant in recent days after Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu encouraged the merger between Jewish Home, a religious Zionist
party, and Otzma Yehudit (Jewish Power), an extremist right-wing party led by
Kahane’s disciples. The merger will increase the united party’s chances of
gaining enough votes to enter Knesset.
Some argue
this is politics as usual. It is quite common for elections to bring out
unsavory tactics in an effort to win.
At the same
time, this is not “business as usual.” Otzma Yehudit includes voices, views,
and personalities that are way outside the mainstream in Israeli life and are
anathema to Jewish values. Adherents express and promote such policies as
expulsion of Arabs who are not "loyal" to the State and strict
segregation between Jews and Arabs. These are policies that do not reflect
traditional Torah values as expressed in public life.
This has elicited strong reactions from across the political and religious spectrum.
Many in
Israel’s religious Zionist camp were outraged. Rabbi Benny Lau wrote:
“As someone
who dreams the dream of the return to Zion, I will fight so the doctrine of
Kahane doesn’t enter the Knesset because it is a racial doctrine like the
Nuremberg Laws.”
Some
criticized the harsh comparison between Jews and Nazis. It’s a sign of how
charged the issue is.
In the US, AIPAC joined American
Jewish Committee (AJC) in condemning the
views of Otzma Yehudit as “reprehensible” and “they do not reflect the core
values that are the very foundation of the State of Israel.”
Malcolm Hoenlein, head of the
Presidents Conference and a prominent leader of the American Jewish community,
noted, “For those who follow this, there’s a lot of concern...What we have
to deal with is how it is perceived and understood in the United States...And
we have to be very careful because it feeds certain tendencies that are very
concerning to us...politics can’t dictate everything.”
These are voices which do not
criticize Israel lightly - certainly not internal Israeli election politics.
It’s unprecedented! That’s a good indication of how important the issue is seen
by the mainstream American Jewish and pro-Israel leadership.
I think the best reason that we
cannot remain silent was expressed by
Yossi Klein Halevi.
This situation is a chilul HaShem,
a desecration of God’s name. Hate and racist ideology have no place in Jewish
politics - even if one thinks it’s necessary for a greater good.
This is a chilul HaShem. That’s why
Jews need to speak out - even if it’s an internal Israeli matter. When there’s
a chilul Hashem, we can’t just sit back and let our Israeli brothers and
sisters speak up. Yes, Israelis - who by and large reject extremist ideology -
will be the ones to decide this issue at the ballot box. At the same time, all
who are dismayed, pained, and outraged by this terrible arrangement can - and
should - express an opinion.
Israel will, please God, survive
regardless of who wins the upcoming elevation. It will thrive when our
connection with and support for Israel are deeply rooted in love and commitment
to Kiddush HaShem, sanctifying God’s name, through our dedication to Torah and
Jewish values.
